Saturday, January 26, 2013
Standing Alone
Lately it seems that I am the only one to be speaking the obvious at my most recent client. I'm again at an organization that is actually treating me like I'm an employee rather than a temp. There are benefits to that as well as some downside.
I don't believe in blowing smoke. If an executive asks my opinion, I give it. More often than not I have found that I am the only one in the room stating the obvious. The rest waits until they see which way the wind blows and then moves in that direction. I'll admit it's an uncomfortable position, but it is not one that I will abandon.
Since I've been with this client for close to a year, you would think by now they would have accepted that I am not a Yes Man. I find it interesting that the executire that made the decision to hire me on is the one most likely to challenge my position yet also the one most likely to absolutely agree with my assessment. It's as if he is challenging his own thoughts.
Which brings me to the point of this post.
For some inexplicable reason tonight I suddenly recalled one of the first times I remember being the only one in the room taking a position where the leader wanted one outcome and everyone just went along.
When I was 13 or so, one of the more popular girls decided she would invite several of us to her church. For the life of me I cannot remember who she was nor any of the other girls that were there. It seems that there were about seven of us.
After church they had some youth meeting in the basement where some youth leader was giving us all a lecture. I recall the guy was giving lectures on the evils of smoking. From the time I was around four and my Aunt Rita had decided to let me have a puff of her cigarette, I have never touched one again. And to this day, that is the only one I ever touched. If you want to teach your kids never to smoke, let them have a puff when they are 4 or 5 and I guarantee you they will never touch one again.
This church leader then wanted all of the girls in the room to pledge they would never touch a cigarette. I distinctly remember I was sitting among the "cool kids", those girls that barely spoke to me at all and the same girls that were well known for finding places to smoke at school.
I suppose the church youth leader thought exerting some peer pressure would get the thirty young girls in front of him to never smoke again.
I wasn't buying it.
I knew that I had no desire to ever smoke, I knew the cool girls next to me would be at it again as soon as they had another chance to prove they were cool and I knew what he was asking everyone in the room to pledge was nothing but a bunch of bull.
He asked all the girls in the room to raise their hands to pledge they would never smoke a cigarette.
Every hand in the room went up, except for one.
I felt awkward, but I also felt a mixture of defiance and honesty and power. With that one act of leaving my hand down when everyone around me was lying, I felt like I was making a decision about my life.
Not about smoking. I was fairly certain I would never touch a cigarette, they seemed as disgusting to me then as they do now.
I felt like I was making a decision that I would not follow the crowd. Whether it be jumping over the cliff or smoking because it was cool or raising your hand to lie in a church.
Not everyone appreciates it when you are the only one in the room saying the Emperor has no clothes.
That's okay with me. I will not be a Yes Man.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
10 comments:
Man, I just had this conversation a couple weeks ago with our plant manager. We were discussing management technique and my place in the chain.
I told him that my sister had ruined me as a child by reading me that story (The Emperors New Clothes).
I realized later in life that the emperor didn't always like to know.
Fortunately he does.
I am of like mind...and it did hurt me in going on to upper management. But my people respected me when I called a Spade a Spade.
Of course my penalty for not going along with the crowd as a kd was being an outcast. I really haven't suffered much in my career for stating the truth. If I do, then I don't have much respect for the executive who would rather ave a Tes Man. That instantly tells me they are too insecure to be an effective leader. You are spot on Coffey.
I don't remember reading that story to you Ed. ;)
I'm often the only one who will make a statement during faculty meetings. It scared me the first time I did it...but knowing you are right is more important than going with the crowd.
Sometimes it will come back to bite you, but once you get a reputation for telling the truth as you know it, you usually gain a some respect. Anybody who is running a business should be thrilled to have someone who will be honest. Of course, there are those who don't want to know the truth, because they are so much more intelligent and wise than the rest of us. (Our current boy king comes to mind...)
Mrs. Who, I think I've been fighting this line battle since I was the unpopular kid in junior high. Not saying I've ever liked being the only one taking a stand, but it's just part of my nature by now.
Babs. I've been on both sides of the fence but usually even when the big bosses don't like what I'm saying, usually they come around with my way of thinking.
Meeting tomorrow to let the execs figure out the deadline will have to move again. Only came about because I told the other project managers I was turning my section of the project red. My responsibilities for this position is testing and training and you can't squeeze two months out of testing and training to catch up a late project without a complete disaster.
Should be interesting.
I commend you!
I got a little gun shy of speaking out when I worked for a large corporation in my mid to late twenties and the grown men in the office (many in their early forties) would get exercised by things I saw wrong in our department and they'd agree they needed addressing ...so we'd all go in and talk to the boss (who was a mean and formidable man)...I'd start the talking, then look around for them to agree and add their experiences to the complaints and they'd be STRUCK DUMB. They wouldn't open their mouths..there I was left to hang.
NOT GOOOOD!! :-)
Of course, I was a founder/Exec VP's niece there and they knew I'd not be fired, and they had children to support, but I found that HORRIBLE and I've been a tad gun shy ever since, now that I think of it!
And that is wrong!
Thanks Z. That stinks what those guys did, but I think that happens more often than not.
It's been a rough couple of weeks at work, but I will stand my ground when I know I'm right. I find it funny when some big guy thinks he's going to intimidate me and instead finds himself at the receiving end of one mad woman. That hasn't worked on me in decades.
Hey Ree, I have been AWOL from blogging and reading blogs. you know the story. I miss reading and writing even though my writing sucks compared to yours and most others who write. I have been writing, to myself on my Iphone. I need to get my shitty blog straightened up and get back to it. No, I don't feel like I have deprived the world of my brilliance. It never has been about impressing anyone, it has been about my need to vent and I still have plenty to vent about. This was a great post and I need to catch up with yours and many other great writers. I as you know, have been concentrating on getting myself back on line and I feel I am close to that end. There are so many things I have had to give up over the last five months. Not writing was self-imposed. I would like to post something on your blog till I get mine back online. love you sis
Anytime Bro. Love you. I have missed you writing with me. I have been in a slump with this whole mess going on right now. There are a million things I want too post but it's just hard to out in all down in a post.
I'm sure I'm not the only one who's missed your writing. I still have my Lincoln movie review hoping to do a he said she said with it.
I'd love to see it again and Zero Dark Thirty.
Post a Comment